4.9
Rated 4.9 out of 5 stars
Based on 72 reviews
5
Rated out of 5 stars
65
Total 5 star reviews: 65 4
Rated out of 5 stars
7
Total 4 star reviews: 7 3
Rated out of 5 stars
0
Total 3 star reviews: 0 2
Rated out of 5 stars
0
Total 2 star reviews: 0 1
Rated out of 5 stars
0
Total 1 star reviews: 0 100%would recommend this product
Slide 1 selected
How did it fit?Rated 0.3 on a scale of minus 2 to 2
Runs small True to size Runs large
Reviews Summary
Generated by AI from 64 most recent customer reviews
Last updated 2 months ago
Customers say this waxed cotton jacket-shirt is well-made, durable, and excellent for cool, wet weather. The heavy material feels quality and keeps them warm and dry during outdoor activities like fishing and hiking. Many note the garment runs large, recommending sizing down. Common feedback mentions initial stiffness that softens with wear. The flannel lining, comfortable fit with room for layering, and versatile style work for both outdoor adventures and casual wear. A few prefer snaps over buttons, and one reviewer noted the lining could be thicker. Overall, customers appreciate the craftsmanship and value.
Customers Talked About
- Fit
- Quality
- Warmth
- Comfort
- Weather Protection
- Material
- Design
72 reviews
- RWGold SprigRandall W.Verified BuyerI recommend this productRated 4 out of 5 stars6 months agoShirt
Mcalister makes awesome waxed canvas clothing! I would recommend sizing up though, especially if you’ve never worn any of their stuff
How did it fit?Rated -1.0 on a scale of minus 2 to 2Runs small Trues to size Runs largeIncentivized reviewThis review was received as part of a promotion or in exchange for an incentive. The incentive was offered to both positive and negative reviews.Was this helpful? - JMSilver DecoyJeremy M. j.Verified BuyerI recommend this productHeight 5' 7"Body Type Broad Shoulders/MuscularSize Purchased 2XLRated 5 out of 5 stars23 seconds agoTrue to size and warm
I’m big boy and I got a 2x and it fits good
How did it fit?Rated 0.0 on a scale of minus 2 to 2Runs small True to size Runs largeIncentivized reviewThis review was received as part of a promotion or in exchange for an incentive. The incentive was offered to both positive and negative reviews.Was this helpful? - LSGold SprigLee S.Verified BuyerI recommend this productUsual Clothing Size XLHeight 6'Body Type StockySize Purchased LRated 5 out of 5 stars1 week agoMcAlister Waxed Cotton Jac-Shirt
Great, versatile shirt. Love it and will last forever.
How did it fit?Rated 1.0 on a scale of minus 2 to 2Runs small True to size Runs largeIncentivized reviewThis review was received as part of a promotion or in exchange for an incentive. The incentive was offered to both positive and negative reviews.Was this helpful? - JMJC M.Verified BuyerI recommend this productHeight 6' 1"Body Type Broad Shoulders/MuscularSize Purchased XLRated 5 out of 5 stars2 weeks agoGreat shirt
It appears to be a great mid fall shirt on cool drafty mornings with a little bit of dew in the air
How did it fit?Rated 0.0 on a scale of minus 2 to 2Runs small True to size Runs largeIncentivized reviewThis review was received as part of a promotion or in exchange for an incentive. The incentive was offered to both positive and negative reviews.Was this helpful? - RGSilver DecoyRoy G.Verified BuyerI recommend this productUsual Clothing Size XLHeight 5' 11"Body Type Broad Shoulders/MuscularSize Purchased XLRated 5 out of 5 stars1 month agoVery Warm & Weather Resistant Jac-Shirt
My wife gave me this for Christmas & I'm glad she did! It is a great fit (XL), warm and weather resistant. It stiff and I know it will take a bit of break in period to make it feel really comfortable, just like I expect! I love waxed cotton clothing and this fits the bill and very good quality.
How did it fit?Rated 0.0 on a scale of minus 2 to 2Runs small True to size Runs largeIncentivized reviewThis review was received as part of a promotion or in exchange for an incentive. The incentive was offered to both positive and negative reviews.Was this helpful?
Loading...
Loading...
Related pages
Use left/right arrows to navigate the slideshow or swipe left/right if using a mobile device